Skip to main content

THE KELLEY'S ISLAND CEMETERY IS ESTABLISHED

IT’S 1854 AND OUR ISLAND CEMETERY IS ESTABLISHED
by Leslie Korenko
This is the history of our Island cemetery, which is quite old. It is a source of meditation, interest, research and an occasional lawsuit. In fact, Ned Williams and a couple of others, are combing through old newspapers to locate and add obituaries for of our Islanders who have passed on. These can be found FindaGrave.com; a great place to find interesting items about Island family members.

The Island Cemetery was  officially established in 1854 with this deed.
“Know all men by these  presents; that I Elizabeth K. Webb of the County of Erie and State of Ohio in consideration of the sum of $18.00 in hand paid by J. E. Woodford, E. Ward, Chas. Carpenter, as Trustees of the Kelleys Island Cemetery Association…do hereby  grant, bargain, sell and convey unto the said Woodford, Ward and Carpenter and  their successors in office forever, the following Premises, situate in the county of Erie, in the State of Ohio and in the Tp. of Kelleys Island…”

This is the first and oldest  section of the cemetery, which is located on Division Street. It is possible  that the lot was used as a burial site much earlier. There are monuments for Eliza and Samuel Titus and Steven and Prudence Titus dated 1851, and were  probably memorial headstones, and there are several references to a cemetery in 1853.

The original cemetery layout  was much more ornate than what we see today. Many plots remain unidentified as  their headstones, some made of wood, are now gone. At one point, even the  original layout vanished and in 1894, the Cemetery Trustees were instructed to find the original chart of the cemetery “if it could be found.”

Officially, the cemetery  contained just 2/3 of an acre.  In 1881 it was expanded by ½  an  acre with a purchase from Fredric Meyer for $450 and a burial lot.

Officials considered another  location for the cemetery instead of increasing its current location. In 1894, the Cemetery Trustees reported to Council on a new cemetery plan. “We   think to take up land in another location and start a new cemetery, the right  course to take, and aside from being a much drier and more beautiful spot and one that can be kept up in better shape. The difficulties now existing in the  old cemetery can be more easily and satisfactorily settled.” Their concern was  that the cemetery was located adjacent to the North Pond and had recurring  drainage problems. The lot they considered purchasing was located on the southeast side of the island. That purchase was not successful and after much  debate, in 1895 another 1.33 acres was purchased from Fred and Matilda Meyer. The boundary of this last expansion was marked by a Maple Tree one foot in  diameter, the stake being on the North side of said tree

The  cemetery sits adjacent to a stream that runs into North Pond. The pond used to drain, but recently, its access to the lake has been blocked by a high sand barrier and the swamp water often threatens to flood Division St.

As the cemetery expanded, roads were laid out, marble tombstones were added to the family plots and a fence was installed. The old fence is still stored on the  cemetery lot.

The  old fence, which had fallen in disrepair, was replaced in 2001; a joint gift  from Edward Kuchar and Jerry West, and O. Hugh Lange and James Palladino who handled  the installation. It really showcases this beautiful, interesting and historic  area.

Prior to the establishment of the cemetery, the dead were buried where convenient. Bodies found in the lake, called floaters, were often buried near where they came ashore. There are  occasional references to the Old Burying Ground located on the farm of Addison  Kelley near the South Pond, but that was assumed to be an Indian burial area. A very few Indian skeletons were uncovered in the area over the years.

The cemetery in 1861 was  described as nothing rich or extravagant with no grand roads to drive upon, no costly iron fences, and no desire to put up any better tombstones than what is  there already. However, just a few years later residents lamented the overgrown  condition of the grounds and the youth of the Island banded together to clean it up and cut back the overgrowth.

On June 16, 1885, the Township Trustees ordered the Clerk to compile a cemetery record and arrange  names of persons buried in the cemetery in alphabetical order. That record  begins in 1854. The cemetery record does not, however, indicate which plot the deceased was buried in, which makes locating many of the graves impossible now.  Since the old records of the Cemetery Board are so incomplete, those buried without benefit of a lasting headstone now lie in unmarked graves. In later  years, an occasional report of plot sales would be given at Council meetings  that identified which lots had been sold or paid for and by whom.

In November 2004, the  cemetery book, which had been missing for several years, reappeared after being  microfilmed at BGSU. It may have been the one identified above. The odd thing is that many names that appear on the cemetery list do not appear on the county  death list and people who appear on the death list may be buried in the  cemetery but do not appear on the cemetery list. In addition, several  people who are on the cemetery list are not actually buried in this cemetery  but  elsewhere. To make matters even more confusing, some entries in the  cemetery ledger are dated before the actual date of death, likely just a  clerical error in transcription.

Many of the monuments or  markers that were installed are now gone and it is likely that many of the  original graves were marked with wooden crosses or markers. In 1913, Lydia  Ryall described the Island cemetery this way. “With its green sward and  flowers, its shrubbery and drooping trees, its artistic and costly monumental  designs, the spot is one of rare beauty and attraction to lovers of ‘the quiet places.’ Attention is soon diverted, however, to the more humble portions of ‘God’s acre,’ where rows of black crosses mark corresponding low mounds. Here rest the bones of Hun and Slav, of Portuguese, Italian, Sicilian, and other  representatives of European peasantry.” Lydia had a poetic spirit. She wrote  mainly about Put-in-Bay.

On March 1, 1886, for the  purpose of keeping the Cemetery Record correctly, it was ordered by the Trustees that persons wishing to bury friends in the cemetery should procure  from the Township Clerk a Burial Permit and before the permit was given, the  permit had to show the name of the deceased, the age and cause of death.

Unfortunately, burials in the  cemetery were not without controversy.
DISAGREEMENT OVER A CEMETERY MONUMENT - November 10 1893 – “A singular  action was filed in the Common Pleas court on Thursday. The plaintiff is Alonzo  B. Dwelle and he names as  defendants Christina Schaedler, administratrix of the estate of the late August  Schaedler, Christina Schaedler individually and the village of  Kelley’s Island. In a lengthy petition filed by Messrs. King and Hall, the  plaintiff says that he has been a resident of the village of Kelley’s Island for more than 42 years. On or about Sept. 8th, 1891, he bought a lot in the village cemetery, described as lot 12 in the addition. The defendant, as  administratrix, claims some right, title or interest in the cemetery and in pursuance of the same has com­menced the construction of and has nearly  completed the foundation for a monument on the line which separates plaintiff’s lot and lot No. 11, one-half of the foundation being on plaintiff’s lot. The defendant has purchased a monument to put upon the foundation so constructed  and threatens to erect the same in a very short time. Plaintiff prays that an  injunction may be issued restraining Mrs. Scheadler from erecting the monument, that an order be made for the removal of the foundation so far as the same has  been constructed and the restoration of the lot to its former condition. A temporary injunction was granted by Judge Kelly, pending the trial of the action.”

Whatever  the problem it appears that it was worked out as Schaedler’s monument is tall  but not overly large. The name on Schaedler’s monument (the most common  spelling) is spelled Scheadler.

The tall  monument is Schaedler’s as well as the smaller monuments. The Dwelle  headstone is in the lower right of the photo. The Schaedler monument  is inscribed: August Scheadler, Died March 25th, 1893, 63 yrs, 7 mos. Albert, Died March 1st, 1891, age 24 years, 4 mos., 11 days. There are individual headstones for Andrew 1858-1927, Mother Christena, Albert, and Father.

The Dwelle headstones are smaller: George F. (1883-1907); Alonzo W. (Father) (1846-1909); Mina D. (Mother) (1859-1931); Norman A. (1882-1913); Rose F (1887-1971); Nelson P. (1880-1967).In our next post, we will share stories about those first burials.

Leslie Korenko is on the Board of the Kelleys Island Historical Assoc. and the author of six books about Kelleys Island history.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

That statue of Mary on Titus Road

It seems like every few years, there is a flood of questions about the statue of Mary located on Titus Road. Rumors abound! One person heard it was created in honor of Island fishermen - a fisherman's shrine if you will. Another was sure it was a memorial to a young couple who died in a car accident at the spot on their wedding day.  These, and the others, are all quite romantic, but unfortunately, not true.  Several years ago, the best history of the statue appeared in our local newspaper, Kelleys Life (the March/April 2012) edition. So, in answer to all those questions, and thanks to Kelleys Life, here is the real story about the Statue of Virgin Mary that we all love so well. By the way, you read several years' worth of Kelleys Life on the museum website - just click on Island Newspapers. (https://www.kelleysislandhistorical.org/kelleys-life-newspaper.html)

A HISTORY OF THE KELLEY'S ISLAND LIME & TRANSPORT CO.

by Leslie Korenko I recently met with Randy Edwards who is a freelance writer doing research for an article on island quarries for Twine Line (Ohio Sea Grant's print magazine). https://ohioseagrant.osu.edu/products/twineline After exchanging several emails, Randy visited Kelleys Island on December 20 to tour the museum and explore our quarry displays. He brought a long list of questions. One item that intrigued him was a nicely detailed article in our display, “The Shays of Kelleys Island” (The Kelley Island Lime & Transport Company’s Kelleys Island operations) by Lee Rainey. This article appeared in the Railroad Model Craftsman magazine, December 1986. It is a treasure trove of information about the early days of quarrying here. Because it contains so much great information about such an important part of our history and was so well researched – we scanned it and shared it with him and now with you. There are some great photos here. We particularly like the long shot

THE OTHER INSCRIPTION ROCK ON KELLEYS ISLAND

THE OTHER INSCRIPTION ROCK ON THE NORTH SHORE By Leslie Korenko We all know that our Inscription Rock on the south shore is world famous, but it seems everyone is suddenly interested in the OTHER inscription rock, which was located in the North Bay near the State Park beach, half way between the boat launch and the swamp. The results of a monumental task, the chronicling of Indian antiquities, was published in 1853. It was an extensive discourse on Indians published by Henry P. Schoolcraft and illustrated by S. Eastman, Capt. U. S. Army. The publication was entitled Information Respecting the History Condition and Prospects of the Indian Tribes of the United States, Collected and Prepared under the direction of the Bureau of Indian Affairs per act of Congress of March 3rd, 1847 . There were five very substantial volumes published between 1853 and 1856. Parts two and three made mention of the pictographs on Kelley’s Island and the history of the Indians in this area. Schoolcraft’s